The Brother’s Ear: Speculation, Weak Instruction, and Other Shortcomings in Schneider by Lisa Haydey and Laraib Khaliqdina
The Brother’s Ear:
Speculation, Weak Instruction, and Other Shortcomings in Schneider
Can a phone conversation between a man and his wife, overheard in part by the man’s brother, be admitted as evidence that the man committed murder? What if the brother who overheard the conversation had been drinking, was under extreme stress, and recalled two different versions of what was said?
This was the complex issue faced by Canada’s highest court, the Supreme Court of Canada (SCC), in R v Schneider. William Schneider was charged with the second- degree murder of Natsumi Kogawa. Previously, Schneider’s brother had recognized the accused in a news release which sought help identifying a man photographed with Kogawa, who was reported missing. The next day, the brother visited Schneider to discuss the news release and witnessed Schneider attempting a fatal heroin overdose, which he survived. Schneider then shared the location of Kogawa’s body and walked ten feet away to telephone his wife. The brother could not recall the exact words Schneider used, but he believed that at one point, Schneider said something like “I did it” or “I killed her.”
At trial, the brother’s testimony was admitted and Schneider was convicted of second- degree murder. However, the Court of Appeal overturned this decision, ordering a new trial that excluded testimony from evidence. The case then went to the SCC. In a split seven-two judgment, the Court decided to admit the testimony and reinstate the trial court’s conviction.
In this blog, we will respectfully argue that the majority’s decision to admit the brother’s testimony was flawed at each step of the analysis: at step one, the evidence was speculative and should not have met the relevancy threshold; at step two, the Court should have considered the reliability of the testimony; and at step three, the jury instructions were too weak to counteract the prejudicial effect of admitting the evidence. Accordingly, we contend that the trial judge erred in including the brother’s testimony.
Click below to read more:
Extra curricular Activities can be nearly anything that does not require any credit or paid wages. We simply do it because we feel happy doing it. These exercises turn out to be essential later. For example, when you are applying for schools, these extracurricular activities can build up your abilities and interests. They can also teach you functional traits like time management.
Need help with your management assignments? Our management assignment help service simplify complex topics and send you coursework on well-researched topics that impress your professors. Don't fret over deadline pressures and hello to better grades. It's affordable, reliable, and quick.
They also provide Essay Typer for students who need help typing essays.
Knowing about the do my online class for me service who contribute to your class will make you happy. The service assigns the top online learner to work when you ask them to help you in their online class. Top graduates from US colleges with a wealth of expertise teaching online are the tutors for the online courses. You don't need to question whether their online tutors are aware of your online learning platform because they have worked on at least 100 classes. Additionally, their online tutors have access to top-notch resources to help them do well on your online class's midterm and final exams. If assigning someone to teach a class can reduce instant academic pressure, it's important to proceed…
In recent years, getting academic assistance online has become more common because it is so easy and convenient for students. Using online assignment help services has numerous advantages, like access to experienced authors, 24/7 customer assistance, and the possibility to get excellent projects inside a certain timeframe. Getting assignment help has one of the main benefits in that it allows one to contact experienced writers with knowledge of several academic fields. These writers can provide you excellent, unique, well-researched projects that satisfy your academic requirements as they are quite knowledgeable about the topic. It also offers the advantage of client assistance. Many web sites have 24/7 customer care, so you may receive assistance day or night. Students who could be working on…
This post is really helpful! For students who need extra support, New Assignment Help is a great option. We provide Homework Writing Services and tailored solutions for assignments, homework, and more. As someone with a master’s degree in Programming Studies, I specialize in helping students with coding tasks and technical projects. Feel free to check us out if you’re looking for reliable academic assistance.